The clinical relevance of methylxanthines as therapeutic agents for improving diaphragmatic contractility is controversial. In a double-blind, placebo-controlled trial, we investigated the effect of aminophylline on the contractility of fresh and fatigued human diaphragm at different lung volumes, and therefore as a function of fiber length. The diaphragmatic contractility of normal subjects was assessed by measurements of transdiaphragmatic pressure changes (Pdi,T) in response to single, bilateral, supramaximal phrenic-nerve shocks during relaxation from total lung capacity (TLC) to functional residual capacity (FRC). Fatigue was induced by resistive breathing. Therapeutic levels of theophylline were reached in all subjects. Under fresh (i.e., nonfatigue) conditions, aminophylline significantly increased Pdi,T at lung volumes above 75% of the inspiratory capacity (IC). Fatigue in the absence of aminophylline caused a disproportionately greater reduction of Pdi,T at high than at low lung volume (J. Appl. Physiol. 1992; 72:1064), which was rapidly reversible with rest. With aminophylline, the disproportionate decrease in diaphragmatic contractility at short fiber lengths was not observed. Aminophylline potentiates diaphragmatic contractility to a proportionately greater extent at short than at long fiber lengths, under both fresh and fatigued conditions. We explain these findings by known effects of muscle shortening, fatigue, and methylxanthines on excitation-contraction coupling mechanisms.