Abstract
Somewhere between 30% and 89% of patients with COVID-19 admitted to a critical care unit require invasive mechanical ventilation. Concern over the lack of adequate numbers of critical care ventilators to meet this demand led the U.S. Food and Drug Administration to authorize the use of anesthesia machines as critical care ventilators. The use of anesthesia machines for ventilating patients with COVID-19 is overseen by an anesthesia provider, but respiratory therapists may encounter their use. This article reviews the fundamental differences between anesthesia machines and critical care ventilators, as well as some common problems encountered when using an anesthesia machine to ventilate a patient with COVID-19 and steps to mitigate these problems.
Introduction
Somewhere between 30% and 89% of patients with COVID-19 who are admitted to a critical care unit require invasive mechanical ventilation.1 Concern over the lack of adequate numbers of critical care ventilators to meet this demand led the U.S. Food and Drug Administration to authorize the use of anesthesia machines (sometimes termed anesthesia workstations) as critical care ventilators.2 This may occur by repurposing operating rooms as intensive care areas or by relocating anesthesia ventilators to the ICU. In both cases, the stated simplicity belies the important technical differences in devices and skills required for safe and effective operation.
Anesthesia machines are multi-component devices in-tended to deliver oxygen (O2) and other gases (eg, nitrous oxide and air) along with volatile inhaled anesthetic agents. The anesthesia machine often includes a physiologic monitor, capnograph, anesthetic gas monitor, and additional monitors. A mechanical ventilator is integrated into the anesthesia machine as one of these components. Anesthesia machines may effectively ventilate critically ill patients but differ significantly from critical care ventilators both in design and operation.3,4 Anesthesia providers (eg, certified registered nurse anesthetists or physician anesthesiologists) should oversee the use of anesthesia machines for patients with COVID-19,3 but respiratory therapists are likely to be involved in their monitoring and use in the critical care unit.
This article provides critical care respiratory therapists with a review of the fundamental differences between anesthesia machines and critical care ventilators. Also examined are the common problems encountered when using an anesthesia machine to ventilate a COVID-19 patient and steps to mitigate these problems. Volatile anesthetics are sometimes administered to patients with severe asthma5 and seizure disorder6 in critical care units. A discussion of this practice is beyond the scope of this article. This information is not intended to replace formal training or manufacturer instructions. Like critical care ventilators, there are many manufacturers and models of anesthesia machines, and readers must follow manufacturer instructions and other guidelines. Readers are referred elsewhere for detailed directions on how to use an anesthesia machine as a critical care ventilator.2-4
Fundamental Differences Between Critical Care Ventilators and Anesthesia Machines
Critical care ventilators deliver breaths containing a variable O2 concentration (), typically set from 0.21 to 1.0. Depending on the ventilation mode selected, the flow of gas from the ventilator can be triggered by patient effort, by settings controlled by the operator (eg, delivering a specified number of breaths per minute), or a combination of these 2 options. A critical care ventilator is capable of a number of modes of ventilation as well as volume, pressure, and adaptive pressure breaths. The critical care ventilator also delivers PEEP and allows control of inspiratory flow, inspiratory time, rise time, and flow termination criteria. Critical care ventilators include a dizzying array of alarms and displays of monitored variables based on airway pressure and flow.
An anesthesia machine delivers oxygen and other gases such as air and nitrous oxide (an analgesic that has some anesthetic properties) along with volatile (also called “inhalational”) anesthetics (Fig. 1). Patients may also breathe spontaneously with no ventilatory support. A positive pressure breath can be delivered either manually by squeezing a breathing bag that is part of the machine or by using the integrated mechanical ventilator. The ventilator may range from a simple bellows-in-a-box device to one approaching the sophistication of a critical care ventilator and deliver patient-triggered breaths. The anesthesia machine may contain a gas and anesthetic monitor, analyzing the inspiratory and expiratory concentrations of O2, CO2, and the volatile anesthetic as well as a physiologic vital signs monitor. Unlike the critical care ventilator, the anesthesia machine is intended to be operated with an anesthesia provider in attendance at all times.
Two of the 5 major differences between critical care and anesthesia machine ventilators are related: potential for rebreathing of exhaled gases and CO2 absorption. The third major difference is the use of a scavenging system to prevent pollution of the room with inhaled anesthetics. The fourth major difference is that may be set using gas flow meters on older anesthesia machine, while is directly set on a critical care ventilator or newer anesthesia ventilator. The final major difference is that manual and mechanical ventilation can be delivered using the anesthesia machine.7 Table 1 contains a summary of these and other differences between an anesthesia machine and a critical care ventilator. These 5 major differences are discussed further below.
Non-, Partial, and Complete Rebreathing
The critical care ventilator operates as a non-rebreathing system where exhaled gases are vented to the atmosphere. The anesthesia machine can operate as a non-rebreathing (also called an open) system where all of the exhaled gases are vented to the scavenging system, as a partial rebreathing (also called semi-closed) system where a portion of the exhaled gases are recycled, or a complete rebreathing (also called a closed) system where all of the exhaled gases are recycled. The anesthesia machine is rarely used as a complete rebreathing system in the operating room; in that setting, the anesthesia machine is often used as a partial rebreathing system to help conserve volatile anesthetics, to reduce costs, and to conserve heat and moisture.7 When used as a partial rebreathing system, the fresh gas flow (ie, the amount of gas in L/min continuously entering the breathing circuit set by the operator, not the flow of gas during inhalation) is less than the patient’s minute ventilation, and the CO2 contained in the portion of the patient’s exhaled breath is chemically removed by the CO2 absorbent.7 In contrast, the anesthesia machine is used as a non-rebreathing system when used with patients with COVID-19. This is primarily done to mitigate problems resulting from excess moisture buildup in the inspiratory limb of the breathing circuit when the anesthesia machine is used with these patients.3,4 This is discussed further below.
Factors or controls determining whether the anesthesia machine is operating as a complete, partial, or non-rebreathing system include the fresh gas flow, adjustment of the adjustable pressure-limiting valve if the patient is breathing spontaneously or being manually ventilated (or analogous valve located with the integrated mechanical ventilator), use of one-way inspiratory and expiratory valves, and the presence of the CO2 absorber.7 Table 2 contains an explanation of terms used when discussing the anesthesia machine and rebreathing. Fresh gas flow and the circle system are discussed further below.
Fresh Gas Flow.
Oxygen and other gases such as air and nitrous oxide are supplied from central pipeline sources or tanks mounted on the anesthesia machine. The anesthesia machine is disabled if there is a loss of the O2 supply pressure. This is a safety system to prevent hypoxic gas mixtures being delivered in the absence of an O2 supply. Regulators in the anesthesia machine reduce the pressure of the supplied gases prior to delivery. The flow of gases (O2, nitrous oxide, air) to the patient are regulated by the anesthesia provider directing setting the flows of the gases on flow meters or by setting variables such as total flow and .7 This gas flow is termed the fresh gas flow and is the amount of new gas added to the breathing circuit each minute.
High fresh gas flow is associated with minimal rebreathing. High fresh gas flows (ie, greater than the patient’s minute ventilation) are used when the anesthesia machine is operated as a non-rebreathing system, which is recommended for patients with COVID-19 to help minimize excessive moisture production in the breathing circuit.3,4 More rebreathing occurs as the fresh gas flow is decreased.7 To emphasize, fresh gas flow is the amount of gas in L/min continuously entering the breathing circuit set by the operator and not the flow of gas mixture provided by the mechanical ventilator during inspiration. The flow of the gas mixture from the mechanical ventilator during inspiration is determined by the settings on the ventilator.
If desired by the anesthesia provider, the fresh gas flow may pass through vaporizers before entering the breathing circuit. These vaporizers convert the liquid volatile anesthetics to a vapor. The vaporizers allow delivery of the anesthetic at the desired concentration. Vaporizers should be removed or drained on anesthesia machines repurposed as critical care ventilators for patients with COVID-19.3,4 The fresh gas flow then flows directly into the circle system.7
Circle System.
The circle system is designed to permit rebreathing of exhaled gases while chemically absorbing exhaled CO2. The flow of gas to the patient circuit is continuous (ie, the fresh gas flow). The simplified patient circuit or circle system includes the adjustable pressure-limiting valve, breathing bag, CO2 absorber, one-way inspiratory and expiratory valves, breathing circuit (usually 22-mm corrugated tubing), and a Y-connector with a heat and moisture exchanging filter (HMEF) (Fig. 2). The adjustable pressure-limiting valve prevents pressure buildup in the system if fresh gas flow significantly exceeds the oxygen consumption of the patient. An analogous valve on the integrated mechanical ventilator performs this function if the patient is mechanically ventilated.7
CO2 Absorption
There is no need for CO2 absorption with a critical care ventilator as no portion of the exhaled gases are recycled. Exhaled gases containing CO2 can be recycled using an anesthesia machine. The CO2 in the exhaled breath must be removed to prevent hypercapnia. CO2 is removed using an absorbent material often soda lime. This commonly used CO2 absorbent contains primarily calcium hydroxide along with small amounts of additional chemicals such as sodium hydroxide. The exhaled breath passes through the granular absorbent before returning to the patient.7
The absorbent does not soak up CO2 like a sponge. Rather, CO2 is chemically removed by converting it to calcium carbonate in a series of chemical reactions. These reactions produce heat and water (Table 3). This water production may be excessive in patients with COVID-19 due, in part, to an increased minute ventilation and elevated CO2 production. The granules of the CO2 absorbent typically contain an indicator. This enables the granules to change color (such as from white to blue or purple) when the absorbent’s capacity has been exhausted. The life of the absorbent is highly variable, depending on factors including the type of absorbent, manufacturer, minute ventilation, patient CO2 production, and the fresh gas flow.7,8
Ability to Deliver Manual and Mechanical Ventilation
The critical care ventilator only delivers mechanical breaths. If required, manual ventilation is accomplished using a separate, manual resuscitator. A non-self-inflating bag is part of the anesthesia machine. This bag is kept inflated by the fresh gas flow. Closing the adjustable pressure-limiting valve and squeezing the bag delivers a manual breath to the patient via endotracheal tube or face mask. An O2 flush valve is present in the anesthesia machine and, when depressed, delivers 100% O2 into the patient circuit at a flow of 35–70 L/min. This high flow of O2 helps when manually ventilating a patient using the anesthesia machine with a face mask in the presence of leaks. The anesthesia machine does not initiate mechanical ventilation automatically.7 The breathing bag/ventilator switch and ventilator controls must be set correctly before mechanical ventilation will begin.
Setting the
Anesthesia machines used as critical care ventilators must be able to deliver air due to the consequences of prolonged breathing of 100% O2. The is directly set on the critical care ventilator. This may be done directly on more modern anesthesia machines, but some anesthesia machines require the use of settings on the flow meters to determine the . For instance, if 1 L/min each of O2 and nitrous oxide are delivered, the is 0.5. If there is a flow meter for air, then setting the O2 and air flow meters will control the (Table 4, Table 5).
is continuously monitored using an O2 analyzer with high and low alarms. Modern anesthesia machines are designed to make it difficult to deliver hypoxic gas mixtures if the system is properly functioning.7 It is nevertheless possible to unknowingly change the setting. This underscores the need for the operator to be near the anesthesia machine.
Scavenging System
There is no need for a scavenging system with a critical care ventilator as the device does not deliver inhaled anesthetics. With an anesthesia machine, exhaled gases that are not rebreathed when operating as a partial or open system exit the circle system. These exhaled gases exit the circle system via the adjustable pressure-limiting valve or another analogous valve in the integrated mechanical ventilator through a system that directs these gases out of the room, as chronic exposure to personnel may be toxic.7 The scavenging hose leading from the anesthesia machine to the wall should be removed if the anesthesia machine is used to ventilate a patient with COVID-19 unless the machine will not function properly without it attached to a wall suction source.3
Excessive Water Production With Rebreathing
Partial rebreathing with lower fresh gas flows, often done in the operating room, requires the CO2 absorbent to chemically remove CO2 from the portion of the exhaled breath that is rebreathed. In the operating room, this side effect of CO2 absorption increases the temperature and humidity of inspired gases. Water and heat are by-products of the reactions of the chemicals in the absorbent and CO2.7,8 This water production is a major problem in patients with COVID-19 because they are often hypermetabolic (ie, high CO2 production) and thus require a high minute ventilation. Large amounts of water are produced, which can occlude the patient circuit and interfere with flow sensors in the anesthesia machine.3 The anesthesia machine should be operated as a non-rebreathing (open) system to mitigate the problem of excess water production from the CO2 absorbent.3,4
Fresh gas flows greater than the patient’s minute ventilation (such as 1.5 times higher) are recommended for patients with COVID-19. Manufacturers and others offer guidance on setting the fresh gas flow (Fig. 3). Some rebreathing may occur even with high fresh gas flows, and the CO2 absorbent should be monitored for color change indicating depletion and replacement as needed. Using a capnograph to detect excess inspiratory CO2 may help determine whether there is unwanted CO2 rebreathing.3,4,7
Heated Humidifiers, HMEFs, and the Anesthesia Machine
Heated humidifiers are rarely used with anesthesia machines. It may not be possible to attach a heated humidifier to an anesthesia machine because the moisture produced may interfere with its operation. Therefore, an HMEF is placed between the endotracheal tube and the patient connector to help conserve heat and moisture (Fig. 4). Importantly, when using an anesthesia machine with a COVID-19 patient, a heat-and-moisture exchanger with an integrated bacterial and viral filter should be used. This positioning helps protect the anesthesia machine from contamination with COVID-19 and from excessive moisture that can affect flow sensors in the machine. This positioning also protects the small-bore sample tubing leading to the gas monitor, thus helping protect the monitor from contamination. The HMEF may become occluded due to copious secretions or by the added moisture from the process of CO2 absorption. This may result in a slow increase in resistance. The HMEF should be routinely inspected and replaced as needed. Protection of the anesthesia machine is also facilitated by placing a filter on the end of expiratory limb where it connects to the anesthesia machine. Decontamination of the anesthesia machine is described in the manufacturer’s instructions.3,4
The Anesthesia Machine Ventilator
Older Anesthesia Machines
Older anesthesia machines were equipped with simple ventilators that solely delivered controlled ventilation. These ventilators were pneumatically powered and controlled. These devices used compressed gas (usually oxygen) to squeeze the bellows to deliver the gas mixture to the patient. These are commonly referred to as bag-in-the-box or bellows-in-the-box ventilators. Older anesthesia ventilators were not capable of delivering spontaneous breathing ventilation modes.7 Many of these anesthesia machines are still in use today and perform well in the operating room with anesthetized patients.7
Newer Anesthesia Machines
Newer anesthesia machines are often equipped with sophisticated, electronically controlled ventilators capable of delivering many ventilation modes. Like older anesthesia machine ventilators, some of these devices use compressed O2 to squeeze a bellows, so demand on the compressed O2 supply is a consideration.7,9-14 Others use an electrically powered piston or turbine to generate inspiratory flow.7,15-17 There is tremendous variability in the features included on these devices, and manufacturers are constantly updating the machines, so the user must consult the manufacturer’s description and directions for use for a specific anesthesia machine (Table 6).
Reports suggest that anesthesia machine ventilators may, however, not perform as well as critical care ventilators for patients with COVID-19. For example, asynchrony and its accompanying problems, including excess airway pressure and patient discomfort, may occur; the asynchrony resolved when the anesthesia machine was replaced with a critical care ventilator.18,19 This evidence suggests that anesthesia machines should be used only if critical care ventilators are not available and should not be used with complicated patients. In addition, experts and experienced providers suggest a critical care ventilator may have to be used if there is difficulty ventilating the patient with an anesthesia machine.3,19
Considerations When Using an Anesthesia Machines For Patients With COVID-19
Stakeholders should consider triage planning such as using anesthesia machines with patients suffering from non-respiratory conditions (eg, trauma, neurologic conditions) and using critical care ventilators with patients with challenging respiratory conditions such as COVID-19. Providers should consider replacing an anesthesia machine with a critical care ventilator if the patient with COVID-19 is ineffectively ventilated when steps such as adjusting ventilator settings (eg, inspiratory time), increasing sedation, and paralysis are not effective.3,4,18,19
Discussed below are general considerations when using an anesthesia machine to ventilate a patient with COVID-19 in a critical care unit. Many agencies, manufacturers, and organizations provide detailed instructions for repurposing an anesthesia machine as a critical care ventilator for such scenarios (Fig. 3). Information includes specific details for determining proper fresh gas flow, preventing contamination, and disinfection of the anesthesia machine. This list is not all inclusive and, like many aspects of this pandemic, resources are frequently revised and new resources become available.
General Planning
All stakeholders, including respiratory therapists, nursing personnel, critical care providers, and anesthesia providers must work together to formulate the policy for using an anesthesia machine for patients with COVID-19 in the critical care unit. Their use must be overseen by an anesthesia provider.2 The policy should include such things as how often the anesthesia provider rounds on the patients, how often an anesthesia machine checkout procedure is required by anesthesia provider, key alarms the non-anesthesia providers must be aware of, and methods of communication with the anesthesia provider.
Patients ventilated using an anesthesia machine should be located in the same unit to facilitate the anesthesia provider’s supervision of their use.2 Room size is a consideration as anesthesia machines are often larger than critical care ventilators. Central O2, air, and suction outlets must be at the bedside. While there usually are 1–2 small O2 cylinders for emergency use on the anesthesia machine, these will become quickly exhausted. Oxygen use is dramatically increased if the anesthesia machine ventilator is pneumatically powered by compressed O2.3,4
Selection and Preparation of the Anesthesia Machine
The anesthesia machine must be capable of delivering patient-triggered breathing modes and air/O2 mixtures, as well as a constant level of PEEP. Personnel from the anesthesia department should prepare the anesthesia machine, including removing or disabling all vaporizers and removing the high-pressure nitrous oxide hose. Flushing the anesthesia machine with high-flow O2 or air helps ensure removal of any residual anesthetic.3,4,20 If the anesthesia machine has an integrated monitor, including a capnograph and anesthetic gas monitor, these monitors should remain intact.
Anesthesia Machine Checkout Procedure
The anesthesia machine may require completion of a checkout procedure prior to use and periodically during use, perhaps as frequently as every 24–72 h. The device may malfunction if this checkout procedure is not performed, and the anesthesia provider should monitor the need for this checkout and perform the checkout preemptively. An alternative ventilation method (eg, another ventilator, a self-inflating bag) should be available because the anesthesia machine cannot be used during the checkout procedure, which may last a few minutes. Considerations include preventing alveolar de-recruitment while using an alternative ventilation method.3,4,18,21
Alarms
Alarms on anesthesia machines typically include alerts for disconnect, high pressure, and high and low , among others. These should be tested and set appropriately, and all personnel should be aware that these audible alarms are not as loud as those on a critical care ventilator. The alarms will likely not interface with the nurse call system or connect with the electronic health record. Personnel must remain close enough to patients ventilated with an anesthesia machine to hear the alarms.2-4 Care of critically ill patients in an operating room repurposed as an ICU presents significant logistical issues. If the patient is provided critical care in an operating room, the ability for caregivers to hear alarms is further diminished.
Setting the Fresh Gas Flow and the
As previously mentioned, an anesthesia machine should be used as a non-rebreathing system. This helps prevent the CO2 absorbent from having to remove as much CO2 and reduces the resultant water by-product. Use as a non-rebreathing system will also extend the supply of CO2 absorbent. Some rebreathing can occur even with high fresh gas flows, so the CO2 absorbent must be left in place and monitored. Fresh gas flow (ie, a combined amount of O2 and air) will determine the , which should be higher than the patient’s minute ventilation. This difference may be as much as 1.5 times the minute ventilation, but recommendations vary between anesthesia machine manufacturers (refer to the manufacturer resources in Fig. 3).3,4 Others report using a fresh gas flow of 10 L/min for adult patients with COVID-19.18 is determined by the flow meter setting, or it can be set directly (Fig. 2). All personnel must take care not to accidentally alter the desired settings, underscoring the need for a qualified operator to be with anesthesia machine at all times.
HMEF and Breathing Circuit Filter
As discussed above, an HMEF should be placed between the endotracheal tube and breathing circuit patient connector (Fig. 4). A filter should be placed between the exhalation limb of the breathing circuit where it attaches to the anesthesia machine.3,4 In the presence of excess humidity, this filter should be monitored for increases in resistance, and it should be changed as needed. The importance of frequent monitoring of this filter cannot be overstated.
Sharing Anesthesia Machines
Authors of a small case series described ventilating 3 groups of patients (2 patients with COVID-19 per group) using a single critical care ventilator.22 The patients were sedated and paralyzed. The authors concluded this could be feasible as a stopgap measure, but safety requires careful patient selection and patient monitoring.22 In one of these 3 pairs of patients, an anesthesia machine was used to provide shared ventilation. In this case, the authors noted that increased HME resistance due to moisture accumulation further exacerbated volume maldistribution between patients. In a 24-h period, they reported changing the HMEF 4 times due to excess water accumulation, as well as issues related to rapid exhaustion of the CO2 absorbent.22 No large studies have been conducted examining ventilator sharing, including anesthesia machine sharing. A consensus statement authored by multiple critical care professional organizations warns against sharing mechanical ventilators. Reasons include volumes preferentially going to the most compliant lung segments, monitoring difficulties, and risking life-threatening treatment failure of the involved patients.23
Potential Problems and Mitigation Methods
Potential problems and those reported when using an anesthesia machine to ventilate patients with COVID-19 are described in Table 7, along with possible causes and mitigation methods. All stakeholders must be keenly aware of the potential for excess water in the breathing circuit. This can lead to obstruction of the circuit and occlusion of the HMEF. Other problems include frequent exhaustion of the CO2 absorbent filter and resulting hypercapnia, ineffective ventilation, and alveolar de-recruitment when the anesthesia machine is disconnected from the patient for various reasons, as well as inability to hear alarms.18,19,24-27
Summary
Anesthesia machines are being repurposed as critical care ventilators during the COVID-19 pandemic.18,24-26,28,29 Their use should be overseen by an anesthesia provider; however, respiratory therapists will be involved in their monitoring and use. Anesthesia machines are fundamentally different than critical care ventilators, and respiratory therapists should be familiar with these differences. All providers must be aware of the potential problems and limitations when using these devices with patients with COVID-19.
Acknowledgments
Special thanks to Michael Dosch PhD CRNA and Shari Burns EdD CRNA for their input and review of this manuscript.
Footnotes
- Correspondence: Paul N Austin PhD CRNA, 14311 Harvest Moon Rd, Boyds, MD 20841. E-mail: paulaustin5{at}gmail.com
Mr Branson is Editor-in-Chief of Respiratory Care. He discloses relationships with Mallickrodt Pharmaceuticals, Pfizer, Ventec Life Systems, Vyaire, and Zoll Medical. Dr Austin has no conflicts to disclose.
- Copyright © 2021 by Daedalus Enterprises